Our guests say it better than we ever could. Here's how Fisher 3 homes rate across every platform they're listed on — and the themes guests repeat, stay after stay.
Fisher 3 homes are reviewed on Airbnb, Vrbo, and our own direct-booking site — and the scores agree with each other.
4.92★ host average
Megan is an Airbnb Superhost with roughly 400 reviews across her listings — individual homes rate from 4.78★ to a perfect 5.0★.
9.8–10 / 10 "Exceptional"
Swimming in Amenities holds a 10/10 Exceptional rating; Swimming in the Woods sits at 9.8/10 with perfect 10s for cleanliness, condition, and check-in.
Top 10% of Airbnb listings
Swimming in Amenities earned Airbnb's Guest Favorite badge — awarded to the most-loved homes on the platform, based on ratings, reviews, and reliability.
5.0★ on our own site
Guests who book direct leave straight five-star reviews — praising the same things: the pools, the game rooms, and hosts who answer fast.
Read a few dozen Fisher 3 reviews and the same six themes surface again and again.
The single most repeated line in our reviews: the home matches the photos — then beats them in person. Swimming in the Sunset scores 4.94 for accuracy on Airbnb.
Perfect 10/10 cleanliness scores on Vrbo and 5.0 on Airbnb — our in-house care team resets every home, pool, and hot tub between stays.
A 99% response rate, replies typically within the hour — and Bell Cottage guests clock Megan's answers at about ten minutes. Hospitality is our top-mentioned review category.
Stocked chef's kitchens, spices and coffee bars, beach gear, cribs and kids' items — guests at Swimming in the Woods note that every cabinet, switch, and remote is labeled.
Reviews describe two and three families sharing one roof comfortably — pools, game rooms, theaters, and fire pits doing the work of keeping everyone in the same place.
"We'd absolutely stay again" closes review after review — holiday groups already planning next year's trip before this year's check-out.
Every home earns its own reputation. Here's how each reviewed stay is rated — and what guests loved most.
Holland
Spotless from top to bottom — the pool and pickleball court kept all sixteen of us busy for days.Airbnb guest
Three generations under one roof and nobody ran out of space. The theater and game room were the family favorites.Vrbo guest
Fennville
The whole crew around one enormous dining table — dinner together every night was the point, and this house made it effortless.Airbnb guest
Immaculate, exactly as described, and every question we sent was answered within minutes.Airbnb guest
Read the reviews on Airbnb
Norton Shores
Three families, thirteen people, zero squabbles — the pool and the game room did the heavy lifting all week.Vrbo guest
Everything is labeled, stocked, and thought through. The most organized rental we've ever stayed in.Vrbo guest
Read the reviews on Vrbo
New Buffalo
The backyard is the show — hot tub, sauna, fire pit under the string lights — and downtown New Buffalo is a short stroll away.Airbnb guest
Beautifully decorated and super clean, and our host replied within about ten minutes every single time.Airbnb guest
Read the reviews on Airbnb
Grand Beach
Wonderful house for a large family reunion — the pool, the kitchen, and the game basement made it perfect.Verified guest, earlier listing
This house is perfect! Comfortable beds, a kitchen that handled our whole group, and the backyard we never wanted to leave.Verified guest, earlier listing
Now direct-book only — check availability
Ratings shown as gathered in July 2026 from each platform. Quotes are paraphrased from recurring themes in guest reviews on the platform credited; Little Arches' rating aggregates its Airbnb/Vrbo review record, with quotes drawn from its earlier listing history.
Four of our stays are brand-new for 2026 — same design standard, same care team, zero reviews so far. Early guests get them before the crowds find out.
Saugatuck's premier retreat — heated pool, hot tub, theater room, and a private lake for kayaking, 1.5 miles from downtown. Freshly launched and already booking heavily.
180 feet of private Kalamazoo River frontage with a dock, kayaks, four decks, and a hot tub over the water — newly added to the collection, minutes from Saugatuck.
Brand-new condos atop Adelaide Pointe on Muskegon Lake — bookable as Residence 601, Residence 602, or the full-floor Penthouse.
Ten stays, six beach towns, and a host team that answers in minutes. Find the home your crew will talk about for years.
